There’s no legal requirement to hire an accountant for your LLC. You can file your own taxes, keep your own books, and handle compliance yourself. The question is whether that’s the best use of your time and whether you’ll actually do it right.

A single-member LLC with straightforward income and expenses can often manage without professional help in the early stages. You track your income, categorize your expenses, and file Schedule C with your personal return. If your business is simple and you’re comfortable with numbers, this works fine for a while.

The math changes once you add complexity. Multiple members means partnership tax returns, K-1s, and allocation rules. Employees mean payroll taxes, quarterly deposits, and compliance requirements. Inventory means tracking cost of goods sold correctly. Each layer adds more opportunities to make expensive mistakes.

Most LLC owners underestimate how much time bookkeeping and tax work actually takes. Setting aside the actual hours, there’s the mental load of knowing you have to do it and worrying whether you’re doing it correctly. That worry costs something even if you can’t put a number on it.

The real risk isn’t getting audited. It’s making decisions based on bad information because your books are a mess, or missing deductions because you didn’t know they existed. A Phoenix area business accountant who understands small businesses will typically save you more in avoided mistakes and captured deductions than they cost in fees.

Here’s a practical test. If you’re spending more than a few hours each month on bookkeeping and tax questions, the time cost alone probably justifies getting help. If your books are six months behind and you’re dreading tax season, you’ve already answered the question.

Some LLC owners try to split the difference by handling day-to-day bookkeeping themselves and hiring someone just for tax preparation. This can work if your bookkeeping is actually accurate. If you hand over messy records, your tax preparer has to clean them up first, and you’re paying for that cleanup at tax time rates.

A cleaner approach is bookkeeping services throughout the year so your records are always ready. Your tax return becomes straightforward because the work is already done. You also get monthly or quarterly visibility into how your business is actually performing instead of finding out once a year.

The decision comes down to what stage your business is at and how you want to spend your time. If bookkeeping energizes you and you’re confident in your tax knowledge, handle it yourself. If it drains you or you’re not sure you’re doing it right, the cost of professional help is usually worth it.